Ads by Muslim Ad Network

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

In defence of Imam Ahmad Raza Khan

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • In defence of Imam Ahmad Raza Khan

    https://khurramsblog123.blogspot.com...raza-khan.html

  • #2
    So....he's a 'wahabi'?

    (ignorant q is sarcasm)

    Comment


    • #3
      Interesting
      Please visit my Youtube cooking channel

      https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCiv...YMkhbbgtX-lL8Q

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by usernametaken View Post
        So....he's a 'wahabi'?

        (ignorant q is sarcasm)
        Asalamu Alaikum

        He was a Hanafi Maturidi, well disciplined in tasawwuf.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by dsr478 View Post

          Asalamu Alaikum

          He was a Hanafi Maturidi, well disciplined in tasawwuf.
          Why don't the barelvis follow this?
          i've also seen or heard about him making comparisons to 'dogs' (not sure if it is him or another brelwi), saying that 'we are dogs' as if it's a good thing in terms of worship and obedience/love

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by dsr478 View Post

            Asalamu Alaikum

            He was a Hanafi Maturidi, well disciplined in tasawwuf.
            Can you confirm the references are authentic?

            Comment


            • #7
              not to be rude brother

              but many barelvis make dua to other than Allah
              grave worship
              and believe prophet comes and sits with them in the masjid
              as well as many other biddah acts

              all contradictory to what your saying
              whats the sources and do other barelvi imams agree with this

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Abu 'Abdullaah View Post

                Can you confirm the references are authentic?
                They're well sourced.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Abu julaybeeb View Post
                  not to be rude brother

                  but many barelvis make dua to other than Allah
                  grave worship
                  and believe prophet comes and sits with them in the masjid
                  as well as many other biddah acts

                  all contradictory to what your saying
                  whats the sources and do other barelvi imams agree with this
                  I gave the sources, you can check them out for yourself.

                  Most Barelvis are not that crazy, they just believe in asking the deceased awliya to make dua for them and that Rasulullah (peace be upon him) sees the actions of his Ummah from the grave.

                  Only some of them do the more crazy stuff.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by usernametaken View Post
                    Why don't the barelvis follow this?
                    They (mostly) do (or at least, the educated ones do).

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by dsr478 View Post

                      They're well sourced.
                      Did you write the post, or have you checked them out?

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        I tried searching for Fataawa Ridwiyyah online but could not find it, i am aware it is a very large work but i would have thought it would be online and we would be able to search through it to verify at least some of the quotes - the only source so far seems to be one guy on a random blog.

                        Other works of Ahmad Riza Khan Braelvi seem to show that he had mushriq beliefs and bidah practices.

                        This video highlights some of the baatil teachings of the sect overall including direct quotes from the founder Ahmad Raza himself in English
                        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7I9GQwRT8Bk

                        and the following exposes some of his corrupt shirki beliefs from his book Malfoozat in Urdu language:
                        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1XMvQ4X90w

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by dsr478 View Post

                          I gave the sources, you can check them out for yourself.

                          Most Barelvis are not that crazy, they just believe in asking the deceased awliya to make dua for them and that Rasulullah (peace be upon him) sees the actions of his Ummah from the grave.

                          Only some of them do the more crazy stuff.
                          This is not true. I had a highly educated practicing Braelvi tell me that Rasoolallah (saw) controls the affairs of the universe - i said this is Shirk - he then paused and added Allah allowed it. Ofcourse they have no proof for this position like most of their baatil beliefs.

                          Another time in middle of a discussion i said to him you realise you are doing Shirk.
                          He said how.
                          I said you make Dua to other than Allah.
                          He said okay sometimes i make Dua to other than Allah.
                          I said that is same as worshiping other than Allah.
                          He said no, its not worship, we just make Dua.
                          I said the Prophet (saw) said the Dua is the essence of worship (hadith).
                          Your praying and asking from other than Allah (swt) constitutes worship.
                          He said you go to the Doctor when your sick.
                          I said yes.
                          He said so that means your also doing shirk.
                          I said no, i said, it is permissible to ask (within reason) from the living, but not the dead.
                          He said the Prophet (saw) is not Dead ! (He got highly offended at this point)
                          I said Abu Bakr (ra) said rasoolallah (saw) is dead, he said this after the Prophet passed away, would you get angry at him? (He had no answer).
                          Then i said okay, we both agree Isa ibn Maryam is alive and raised to the heaven awaiting return ?
                          He said yes.
                          I said so Isa ibn Maryam is not dead, he is alive.
                          He said yes.
                          I said that means its okay to ask your needs from Isa ibn Maryam ??
                          He paused and ofcourse yes !

                          I said you got your path, i got mine. You think its okay to pray to Isa ibn Maryam for your needs, then goodluck, your just like the christians and the shias.

                          That was end of our discussion that day.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by dsr478 View Post

                            I gave the sources, you can check them out for yourself.

                            Most Barelvis are not that crazy, they just believe in asking the deceased awliya to make dua for them and that Rasulullah (peace be upon him) sees the actions of his Ummah from the grave.

                            Only some of them do the more crazy stuff.
                            making dua to the dead is shirk

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by dsr478 View Post

                              I gave the sources, you can check them out for yourself.

                              Most Barelvis are not that crazy, they just believe in asking the deceased awliya to make dua for them and that Rasulullah (peace be upon him) sees the actions of his Ummah from the grave.

                              Only some of them do the more crazy stuff.
                              R u baralwi
                              Please visit my Youtube cooking channel

                              https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCiv...YMkhbbgtX-lL8Q

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X