Re: The original Najdi/ Wahhabi movement was more extreme in bloodshed & Takfir than
I understand what your saying about the khariji type opinion, I will have to think about this because scholars in the past have made takfeer on strange things before him aswell, they were mistaken but to call it khawarij takfeer seems incorrect aswell. As for it being extreme and incorrect, yes I agree with that actually and I actually have held this view for a few years now
Besides that, what I'm trying to say that his dawah and war against the mushrikeen as a whole was still correct, even if he was mistaken on this opinion
1) That seems correct, no one called it shirk akbar as far as I know before the scholars of najd,
2) This is completely wrong, a number of scholars said this act is not permissible, il post a few statements in the next post, however as you rightly stated, none of them called it shirk akbar and made takfeer on Muslims over it for doing that alone, they just stated it's not permissible or a bidah
I agree, salafis should reject incorrect views no matter who they are from,
بارك الله فيك
Originally posted by AmantuBillahi
View Post
Besides that, what I'm trying to say that his dawah and war against the mushrikeen as a whole was still correct, even if he was mistaken on this opinion
1) That seems correct, no one called it shirk akbar as far as I know before the scholars of najd,
2) This is completely wrong, a number of scholars said this act is not permissible, il post a few statements in the next post, however as you rightly stated, none of them called it shirk akbar and made takfeer on Muslims over it for doing that alone, they just stated it's not permissible or a bidah
I agree, salafis should reject incorrect views no matter who they are from,
بارك الله فيك
Comment