Ads by Muslim Ad Network

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

book club

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Props to anyone who's able to read this entire book:

    "Ar-Rad Alal Mantiqiyin - Refutation of the logicians - Ibn Taymiyyah"

    https://www.academia.edu/11621102/An_Islamic_Refutation_of_Aristotelian_Logic_Transl ation_of_Ibn_Taymiyya_Part_I_

    Comment


    • Originally posted by AmantuBillahi View Post
      Props to anyone who's able to read this entire book:

      "Ar-Rad Alal Mantiqiyin - Refutation of the logicians - Ibn Taymiyyah"

      https://www.academia.edu/11621102/An_Islamic_Refutation_of_Aristotelian_Logic_Transl ation_of_Ibn_Taymiyya_Part_I_

      "Sharh Aqeedah al-Tahawiyya - Ibn Izz al-Hanafi"

      https://kalamullah.com/Books/Comment...i-Part%201.pdf

      https://kalamullah.com/aqeedah.html

      Comment


      • Ummdatu Al-Ahkam- Imam Al- Maqdisi

        Bulugh Al-maram- Ibn Hajr Al-Asqalani

        Very important books for whoever is interested in studying fiqh.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by Farah. A View Post
          Ummdatu Al-Ahkam- Imam Al- Maqdisi

          Bulugh Al-maram- Ibn Hajr Al-Asqalani

          Very important books for whoever is interested in studying fiqh.
          U study 2 madhubs?

          Comment


          • Originally posted by Farah. A View Post
            Ummdatu Al-Ahkam- Imam Al- Maqdisi

            Bulugh Al-maram- Ibn Hajr Al-Asqalani

            Very important books for whoever is interested in studying fiqh.
            English translation?

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Abu julaybeeb View Post

              U study 2 madhubs?
              No. I am currently studying umdatul Alahkam only.
              Actually the two books don’t belong to a specific madhab. It is just a collection of ahadith on fiqh rulings.

              Umdatul ahkam is a collection of ahadith from the sahehayn ( Muslim and Bukhari)

              bulugh Al-maram is a collection of ahadith from 7 sources ( Bukhari, Muslim , abu dawoud, termzi, etc..)

              it is better to start with umdatul Ahkam.
              Last edited by Farah. A; 13-11-19, 10:14 PM.

              Comment


              • Originally posted by AmantuBillahi View Post

                English translation?
                Yes it is available in English. You will find a lot of explanations for the ahadith so be careful which one you gonna choose. You can find YouTube videos too

                Comment


                • Reliance of the Traveller - Shafi'i Fiqh Manual:

                  https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&sour...wV-jSCT49RCm4d

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by Farah. A View Post

                    No. I am currently studying umdatul Alahkam only.
                    Actually the two books don’t belong to a specific madhab. It is just a collection of ahadith on fiqh rulings.

                    Umdatul ahkam is a collection of ahadith from the sahehayn ( Muslim and Bukhari)

                    bulugh Al-maram is a collection of ahadith from 7 sources ( Bukhari, Muslim , abu dawoud, termzi, etc..)

                    it is better to start with umdatul Ahkam.
                    Bulugh al maraam is predominantly used by shafiee tullab

                    umdat al ahkaam is predominantly used by hanbalis

                    due to the authors of each book being inclined to their specific madhub


                    they should be studied after simple fiqh text
                    Such as

                    hanbali- umdah al fiqh
                    shafiee- matn abi shajaa

                    the classical way to study is to study one madhub then after mastering it you do comparative fiqh
                    however with the spread of 'salafia' in the 20th century many have started studying comparative fiqh from the get go which is alot harder


                    to be honest my teacher taught me comparative and it was alot harder and longer
                    Last edited by Abu julaybeeb; 14-11-19, 12:31 AM.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by AmantuBillahi View Post

                      English translation?
                      Bulugh al maram pdf on internet /also book
                      umdat al ahkaam only book as far as i know available on kitaabun site (may have spelt it wrong)

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Abu julaybeeb View Post
                        Bulugh al maraam is predominantly used by shafiee tullab
                        umdat al ahkaam is predominantly used by hanbalis
                        due to the authors of each book being inclined to their specific madhub
                        they should be studied after simple fiqh text
                        Such as
                        hanbali- umdah al fiqh
                        shafiee- matn abi shajaa
                        the classical way to study is to study one madhub then after mastering it you do comparative fiqh
                        however with the spread of 'salafia' in the 20th century many have started studying comparative fiqh from the get go which is alot harder
                        to be honest my teacher taught me comparative and it was alot harder and longer
                        umdatu alahkam is different from umdatul fiqh.
                        Umdatu fiqh is a hanbali book.
                        undatul alahkam is classified as a hadith book like 40 hadith of imam nawawy but umdatu al ahkam is mainly on rulings
                        As far as i know these two books are recommended for beginners who don’t follow a madhab and they are explained by scholars from different madhab. Have a look on the books and you will understand what i am saying.

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by Farah. A View Post

                          umdatu alahkam is different from umdatul fiqh.
                          Umdatu fiqh is a hanbali book.
                          undatul alahkam is classified as a hadith book like 40 hadith of imam nawawy but umdatu al ahkam is mainly on rulings
                          As far as i know these two books are recommended for beginners who don’t follow a madhab and they are explained by scholars from different madhab. Have a look on the books and you will understand what i am saying.
                          Lol i know i have them at home

                          umdat al ahkaam is a fiqh commentary hadith book writtem by abdul ghani al maqdisi (hanbali)
                          where as umdah al fiqh is a pure fiqh book written by abu qudama al maqdisi (hanbali)

                          they were cousins

                          buloogh al maraam author ibn hajr asqalami was shafiee

                          yes nowadays people will study as you said those text from beginning but before people would go through simpler texts before at the beginning

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by Abu julaybeeb View Post

                            Lol i know i have them at home

                            umdat al ahkaam is a fiqh commentary hadith book writtem by abdul ghani al maqdisi (hanbali)
                            where as umdah al fiqh is a pure fiqh book written by abu qudama al maqdisi (hanbali)

                            they were cousins

                            buloogh al maraam author ibn hajr asqalami was shafiee

                            yes nowadays people will study as you said those text from beginning but before people would go through simpler texts before at the beginning
                            Ah sorry I thought you were confused.

                            the problem is that i am not inclined to one madhab yet so I thought of starting with umdatul Ahkam

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Farah. A View Post

                              Ah sorry I thought you were confused.

                              the problem is that i am not inclined to one madhab yet so I thought of starting with umdatul Ahkam
                              The goal of a student should be to learn all madhaaib but its easy to start with one master than then move on if Allah wills

                              to decide which to start with id say look at the madhubs usool as that is what is used for fiqh


                               
                              Attached Files

                              Comment


                              • I decides to do hanbali but if i look back at it i may have done shafiee due to the usools priority of qiyaas instead of¬† daeef ahdith

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X