Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

[AbulUthman]

Why are there different harkaat, in the two, specially waqf lazim (Obligatory stop),
E.g: Surah Yasin, Ayah 13 and Surah Nuh Ayah 4

[sliceruk]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

I suggest Uthmani script, if later on, you want to Learn Arabic, it will be better for you.

[AbulUthman]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

I suggest Uthmani script, if later on, you want to Learn Arabic, it will be better for you.

Ok :jkk: for your advice,
But that doesn't answer my question.?

[sliceruk]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

I just checked, this is strange.

[TalibIelm]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

As Salaam Ulaikum Wr Wb Brother,

Please have a look at the explanation below

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Wk0LYLjbCY

NOTE: Its a sister explaining it in detail but no picture - just her voice.

May Allah guide us and all of us towards the right path. Ameen

[.mirror.]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

As Salaam Ulaikum Wr Wb Brother,

Please have a look at the explanation below

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Wk0LYLjbCY

NOTE: Its a sister explaining it in detail but no picture - just her voice.

May Allah guide us and all of us towards the right path. Ameen

:wswrwb:

:jkk:

Interesting. Though, she didn't explain about waqf lazim.

[TalibIelm]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

:wswrwb:

:jkk:

Interesting. Though, she didn't explain about waqf lazim.

I think its in the 8th or 9th part if i am not wrong but she has not gone in a great detail about it.

Rumuz Al Awqaaf >> http://www.ilmgate.org/the-preservation-of-the-quran/

Wa Antum Fajazakamullah Khairan

[Muslimah~S]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

That video is helpful. I always wondered why people kept saying the Indo Pak one was easier to read, whereas I was finding it very difficult. This thread actually reminds me of one time I was looking for a mushaf online and it said the Uthmaani script one was not suitable for South Asians. I was like erm okay, not all South Asians read the Indo Pak script.

[AbulUthman]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

I just checked, this is strange.

My mufti sahab says it's cuz Quran has been revealed in 7 dialects, there's a Saheeh hadith regarding it !

[sliceruk]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

My mufti sahab says it's cuz Quran has been revealed in 7 dialects, there's a Saheeh hadith regarding it !

Yes, but both the Uthmani and Indo-Pak is in Hafs, as in the image posted above.

[AbulUthman]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

Yes, but both the Uthmani and Indo-Pak is in Hafs, as in the image posted above.

So what's the reason they have difference in waqf lazim, one having none, other having a waqf lazim in certains ayahs, when it is obligatory to stop?
In terms of phonetics, I love Uthmani mushaff, but I'm still confused, !!!

[AbulUthman]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

As Salaam Ulaikum Wr Wb Brother,

Please have a look at the explanation below

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Wk0LYLjbCY

NOTE: Its a sister explaining it in detail but no picture - just her voice.

May Allah guide us and all of us towards the right path. Ameen

:aku_wsalam:
I have read the rules in great detail of both the musshaff, just confused about that waqf lazim thing !??

[the_middle_road]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

Why are there different harkaat, in the two, specially waqf lazim (Obligatory stop),
E.g: Surah Yasin, Ayah 13 and Surah Nuh Ayah 4

The Qur'an at first had no stop signs included. They were added much later. So they aren't rules as such, more of just guidelines. And it is based on the ijtihad of the ones who included them. That's why you'd find different stops in different masaahif.

[TalibIelm]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

:aku_wsalam:
I have read the rules in great detail of both the musshaff, just confused about that waqf lazim thing !??

Akhi Insha Allah i will post a answer soon on this and maybe if you can tell me exactly what is confusing you would help.

Need to get it checked before i post it here.

HOW TO RECITE >>> Wa Ađrib Lahum Mathalāan 'Aşĥāba Al-Qaryati 'Idh Jā'ahā Al-Mursalūn

[AbulUthman]

Re: Comparison between Uthmani and Indo-Pak Mushaf

Akhi Insha Allah i will post a answer soon on this and maybe if you can tell me exactly what is confusing you would help.

Need to get it checked before i post it here.

HOW TO RECITE >>> Wa Ađrib Lahum Mathalāan 'Aşĥāba Al-Qaryati 'Idh Jā'ahā Al-Mursalūn

I think brother middle road answered me, :jkk: for your concern akhi !
Wouldn't mind if you post another answer, I mean waqf lazim is obligatory to stop on , in surah yasin ayah 13, as sliceruk attached it, uthmani has no stop, while the indopak has the waqf lazim, what is the reason of this difference??