Ads by Muslim Ad Network

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Nashmia
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    personally i don't see a problem with it at all. not all divorced guys are bad. some have married in the family and not happy. they usually think because it's in the family they have to make it work, but it's the biggest misconception, and when they realize that actually its better to be as far away as possible, i.e divorce then they can be free to marry those they feel is right. it's actually more problematic to remain in marriages with family members, from a lot of the cases you hear of. because then they start to form ties with you and interfere slowly, and the guy or the girl reports back different things because it's family, and the whole of his family and whole of her family integrate and basically the guy is the puppet with the strings. he has to break those strings, so to speak to be free to follow what Allah swt has given him the rights to choose and only then can the couple who are not related make decisions for themselves only.

    other reasons are that, that the girl isn't happy and many other things. but you do your research for all guys whether single or not. you just have to do your bit including istikhara, and as long as he's not hung up on the previous girl, I don't mind.

    Leave a comment:


  • aekbal
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    nice post, something i am struggling with at the moment,
    the majority of sister I come across have a issue of how the family will accept me and my past, it truly makes me think is there really anyone?

    Leave a comment:


  • naila-k
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    My friends brother got married then went back to the country he was working, and in that time before rukhsiti there were a few misunderstandings, like he viewed her as his wife and she didnt like the way he talked to her, he thought she demanded too much stuff etc then before living together they got divorced,

    i dont think either of them had any emotional baggage in this situation. the girl was only 16, and they were related as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sam_87
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    Originally posted by Kya View Post
    As much as I try to be open minded, I often find myself not to be as open minded when I am facing the situation. When i see a brother with divorce status, I am reluctant to get to know him because:
    1) What will people say? Even if my parents agree, there will be others making comment. Do I really want to hear all those for a guy I don’t know? Of course I will get to know him before marriage but do I really want to get to know him?

    Who cares?


    2) Emotional damage his divorce brought to him. Breakup is bad but divorce is worst and on a young guy with no life experience, that will have huge impact on him. Do I want to deal with it? But of course not every brother has those issues. Again the question comes do I really want to find out the depth of his emotional damage

    Maybe there wasnt an emotional damage? Or maybe it is because of his marriage breaking down that has turned him into a better person...
    more humble? Or maybe he will appreciate his new wife more now that he has been been divorced (assuming his ex wife had bad character) or he will try his hardest with his new wife as he has already a "failed" marriage on his hands.

    3) If a brother is married at young age, old enough to be looking for his 1st marriage, then I worry about his decision making skill. Is he just terrible at picking girl and if so I am another bad choose or has he learned his lesson?

    Or maybe its what we call QadraAllah

    I feel really weird dealing with this situation. I am usually reluctant to get to know a guy because i envision 101 problems before I even met him.
    I think people should stop being so scared of "divorcees", it really isnt a big deal...its just something that can happen to any of us....today youre sat here telling us about this proposal, but who knows...5 years from now you could be divorced yourself (Allah forbid) so we should try being more understanding.

    In shaa Allah, you should pray Istikhaara and stop stressing yourself over all these ifs :)

    Leave a comment:


  • *~ Shrinking Violet ~*
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    Originally posted by geeksupremo View Post
    I'd definitely ask him why his previous marriage ended and do some background research, just to be on the safe side. It could be that he got divorced for some valid reasons, but still it wouldn't hurt to check, see if he has a record of domestic violence, substance abuse and things like that.
    :up: I agree. (Personally) I'd go as far as to say that it's essential to do so. I mean, what if he's a serial womaniser etc?

    Leave a comment:


  • muslimahc
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    It depends on his character and why he got divorced. If he has a good character and doesn't have kids, then I would marry him. If they have kids, then that would be an attachment between them I don't want. I also want to be sure that he is not still in love with his ex wife.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kya
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    As much as I try to be open minded, I often find myself not to be as open minded when I am facing the situation. When i see a brother with divorce status, I am reluctant to get to know him because:
    1) What will people say? Even if my parents agree, there will be others making comment. Do I really want to hear all those for a guy I don’t know? Of course I will get to know him before marriage but do I really want to get to know him?
    2) Emotional damage his divorce brought to him. Breakup is bad but divorce is worst and on a young guy with no life experience, that will have huge impact on him. Do I want to deal with it? But of course not every brother has those issues. Again the question comes do I really want to find out the depth of his emotional damage
    3) If a brother is married at young age, old enough to be looking for his 1st marriage, then I worry about his decision making skill. Is he just terrible at picking girl and if so I am another bad choose or has he learned his lesson?

    I feel really weird dealing with this situation. I am usually reluctant to get to know a guy because i envision 101 problems before I even met him.

    Leave a comment:


  • geeksupremo
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    Originally posted by Kya View Post
    Let’s be honest and no politically correct answer of we treat everyone equal. Tell me how you truelly feel and what you honestly will do if you obtained a proposal from someone who is near your age group or in their 20’s but is divorced. You don’t know the reason and you don’t know the person character or much about the person.

    Would you move forward and look into it or would you walk away because being divorce at such a young age is red flag.

    My view: I have uttermost respect for divorce brother and sister, it just happens. I don't think I am willing to deal with it at this point.
    Originally posted by sushi View Post
    When I was single, I got a proposal from a divorced brother. Tbh, I would love to consider that proposal but as my parents wouldn't want me to marry a divorced brother at that point, I couldn't go forward with that. However, I feel one should inquire why the previous marriage didn't work once everything seems to be ok between the brother and sister. This will also help to understand this brother more inshAllah.
    :salams

    I wouldn't mind if I got a proposal from a young divorcee, though I know my family would make a fuss about it I'd definitely ask him why his previous marriage ended and do some background research, just to be on the safe side. It could be that he got divorced for some valid reasons, but still it wouldn't hurt to check, see if he has a record of domestic violence, substance abuse and things like that.

    Leave a comment:


  • sushi
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    When I was single, I got a proposal from a divorced brother. Tbh, I would love to consider that proposal but as my parents wouldn't want me to marry a divorced brother at that point, I couldn't go forward with that. However, I feel one should inquire why the previous marriage didn't work once everything seems to be ok between the brother and sister. This will also help to understand this brother more inshAllah.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hayaa
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    Originally posted by Kya View Post
    Would you move forward and look into it or would you walk away because being divorce at such a young age is red flag.
    Been there, done that. I was briefly engaged to a 'young' divorcee once. Personally, I think not all 20'ers are irresponsible just as not all oldies are man enough. Red flag for me would probably be a guy who divorced his wife of 10 years leaving his kids behind than a 20 something who is divorced within the year of his marriage.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kya
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    Obviously one would not know much about a prospect until she agrees to look into the proposal & then find out.

    If it is a person who is from our inner social circle then it is easier to decide. But most proposal are from 3rd degree where not much information is known untill we decide to walk down the

    Leave a comment:


  • Massilia
    replied
    Re: Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

    Honestly I don't care about the divorce, even im a very very very curious person, I'd try not to ask why. But the "I dont know much about the person" is more worrying no?

    Although at the first little stunt i'd be out obviously

    Leave a comment:


  • Never married sisters: How do you feel about young divorced guy?

Working...
X