Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

[Gingerbeardman]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

You ought to come meet the locals.
Proper Pakistani People.
In Salwaar Kameez even in the winter.
What is this nonsense about being embarrassed.

Pakistan is less than 100 years old.
Whereas the culture is a lot older and spans all across the Asian region.
Nationality can change and so can identity.
Use it or lose it.

Majority of 'ethnics' in the West are products of the West.
They have been fed and nurtured by the West.
It's a fact.
They don't intentionally try to lose older cultural values.
It's merely a consequence.

Wait till you see the next generation Somali's.
Unless the community as a whole makes and effort, they will end up Western.

already happening, I can remember how rare it was when I first became Muslim to meet westernized somalis, you'd get secular somalis, but not outright westernized ones. Now you do.

[thebench]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

I really don't like talking about my ethnicity and where I was born/citizenship. Cos I always get side-glances from people of my ethnicity, like they don't believe I'm Somali.
I was born in Norway but raised in the UK, so which should I claim, and would they 'claim' me back?

Why would they not believe you?

[LailaTheMuslim]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

Why would they not believe you?

right, I always get "you don't look somali" often from annoying youngsters from my ethnicity, I don't think adults would say that

[thebench]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

right, I always get "you don't look somali" often from annoying youngsters from my ethnicity, I don't think adults would say that

What do they say you look like? I think I say that sometimes. It just comes out. Especially when it comes to Barawanis. It's amazing how diverse Somalis are. You don't see that with English people for example.

I can see how it would be annoying.

[Thunderstorm]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

"Hi. Bob Evergreen here. And today I'm going to share the Jospel of Gesus Christ with you."


WOULD YOU?! :D
No, I think everybody should play to their strengths, and not try too hard.

[Linkdeutscher]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

I don't think the majority are, though some may be.

[Rifqah]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

Ethnicity is different to nationality. I was raised in England, as was my father as well. But ethnically I am Irish and I would never say I am English, they are a different ethnicity, and the more I study history and indeed present day culture the less I would wish to be associated with them.

So I would say I am Irish by ethnicity, or British if you ask my nationality.

I think I mentioned ethnicity didn't I? Yes it seems I did.

I'm not ethnically Welsh. I wouldn't consider you ethnically Irish either. If you consider yourself to be so then that's fine if you feel comfortable saying that about yourself.

[LailaTheMuslim]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

What do they say you look like? I think I say that sometimes. It just comes out. Especially when it comes to Barawanis. It's amazing how diverse Somalis are. You don't see that with English people for example.

I can see how it would be annoying.

Peeps say I just don't look very Somali, perhaps South African, Kenyan, once in high school a friend (who is jamaican) said that I looked Caribbean.

Honestly this happened more when I didn't wear hijab

[Gingerbeardman]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

I think I mentioned ethnicity didn't I? Yes it seems I did.

I'm not ethnically Welsh. I wouldn't consider you ethnically Irish either. If you consider yourself to be so then that's fine if you feel comfortable saying that about yourself.

It may be true in your case, but ethnicity is a matter of lineage, not just where you were born or raised.

[n0.n4m3]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

already happening, I can remember how rare it was when I first became Muslim to meet westernized somalis, you'd get secular somalis, but not outright westernized ones. Now you do.

The main difference is that Somalis only have been in the west since the early 90s but Desi's have been in the West for longer.
There are more westernized Desis than there are Somalis probably because Desis have been in the UK longer than Somalis. I don't think there's anything else. The main difference is time. Not necessarily whether one is liberal or conservative.

[cuezed]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

:confused:It's awkward. Someone asks me where I'm from. I'll be like birmingham or pakistan?

[HelloEverybody]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

I say I'm Bangladeshi mainly to differentiate myself from others. It sets up different set of expectations on you, I suppose.

If discussion goes further on the subject I explain I was born in here.

[Losttraveler]

Re: Are South Asians really embarrassed of their origins?

I don't think so. Why to be embarrassed.
As a matter of fact majority of people think I am Arab due to my abaya n naqab but I clear their misconception at the spot "NO NO I AM FROM PAKISTAN" :D