Poll: Do you support the Saudi proposal?

[Nighthawk]

Do you support the Saudi proposal for Israel to return to the pre-'67 borders in exchange for peace & recognition?

[Nighthawk]

Okay, a question for those who are saying no....

Why not?

[kaleem26]

saudi peace proposal contradicts islamic sharia....there fear of allah swt is extremly sad.

[khilafah]

Voted "no" for pretty much the same reason Kaleem did.

Contradicts shari'ah law.

Also, I don't believe in rewarding criminals, theives and terrorists, which is what the zionists are for stealing any of the land to begin with.

So if we accepted this idea, and gave them a certain % of the land, we'd be rewarding theft, and that's also against our principles.

[Bilal]

I support it, but it should be more clear about:
1) Complete Independance
2) Refugees

[khilafah]

Bilal,

Do you believe in the Shari'ah?

[Hierophant]

I said no for pretty much the same reason khilafah did. Rewarding ppl for their terrorism is against all that i stand for. the pals made a big mistake electing a terrorist, and sadly for them, they are paying for it, but not the only ones paying for it.

[Malcom]

What Plan? They had an Idea to "Start"a plan, but it never got any further than that. Give back land and shazam peace? Like the peace Israel enjoys with Hezbollah after they pulled out of Lebonon in 2000? Any plan that doesn't address the groups that want to destroy Israel is not a plan!

[khilafah]

Hierophant, Elect?

Arafat was "elected" by USA and Israel as the only Palestinian leader they felt they could do "business" with. He was not elected by the Palestinian people.

Also, what's your take on the Zionists electing Sharon? A well known war crminal and terrorist? Even Yitzak Rabin was a terrorist and arms smuggler too.

[kaphirgoyim]

I support it because it is the only one offered BY ARABS , for Palestine (short of Sodamm's solution).

(edit, changed BY MUSLIMS to BY ARABS to be more accurate, thanks Khilafah).

It's still better than nothing.

[khilafah]

It's not offered by Muslims at all, nor is it based on Islam.

It is offered by a member of the Saudi family, a family of Western agents, who've been loyal servants of the British empire and later the Americans for the past 250 years.

This is a family who assisted the British in waging a war against the Islamic Khilafah State (of the Uthmania/Ottomans) which finally led to its dissolution and the climate in which Palestine could be taken by the Zionists.

Is it no wonder now that this treacherous agent comes forward and offers a proposal to formalise and normalise the giving away of the Muslim lands?

[friendly in tex]

within the "67" border! I also don't thnk that peace will continue no matter what is given up by the Israelis! Saudis, Iraq, Iran will never allow Jews to have peace! It is a wated effort!



Originally posted by Tyler Durden
Okay, a question for those who are saying no....

Why not?

[Yasin Islam]

No because, the Saudi regime is treachorous! There isn't too much in it for the Middle East and North Africa, let alone Palestine. This peace initiative is to the benefit of Israel.

If this initiative is taken by Palestine, not much will change. All we will see is another USA in the middle East who will bully around all the countries surrounding it.

Any initiative must include the disarming of Israel like Iraq is being disarmed.