Which Madhab do you follow [Archive] - Page 2 - Ummah.com

TOPYES

16-12-06, 02:13 PM

Salafi's are those who claim the true followers of the Salaf (The word Salaf means arabic is people of the past)
1> You might ask yourself are they new group well No, they change name's every centry to confuse the people.
2> Who are they? Check from the internet what the scholors of Ahli sunna say, by searching the internet NUH HAMIIM KALLER.
2> What is there AQIIDA> Well you see They say we take the quran as it is with out looking any other meaning for it such as, were Allah says (Arahman alil arshi istawaa) to the near meaning the mercifull ( your lord ) is in his Arsh ( kingdom ) so they say Allah is up. There's onother group who says no Allah is everywhere because they say Allah say's inthe Quran: Where there's two i'm the thirth, were there three i'm fourth and so on.
So the Salafi's say we have sahiih hadith to proof our point such as the slave woman when she was asked by the prophet were is allah she said up but the othe group say's we have sahiih hadiths such as the saying of the prophet between the qibla and the person who is praying there's Allah also do you remember when the Prophet and Abuubaka was leaving Madina and they hide inside the cave and Abuubakar got worried and the prophet said who can harm too who the thirth is Allah.
QUES > What do the Salaf say abou these two groups?
ANS > Well the four imams and there followers say we should leave these verses as only Allah knows best, The Imam shafi'a use to say about these verse how the Prophet understood and never use to mention how.
But when these groups came out used known as: Kawaarij, The tabi'iin scholors such as Imam Yusuf a Dahaawi draw the line and save the Umma he was student of the great Imaam Abu Hanifa he lived the best time as the prophet said the best group is my As haaba then tabi'an then tab;taabi;n, He wrote the book of Aqiida Ahli Sunna waljama'a he said dont be confused dont say Allah is in his Arsh or down or left or right as Allah excisted before derection also know the Arsh is makh luuq menaning created thing just like you and me, Allah was Malik beffore he created anything his quility do not change just like you and i, One day we are poor the next day we are king Allah is not in need bu we are in need, The Prophet said No eye has ever seen no mind can ever imagine what Your lord has perpare for you to the As haaba ( how can we imagine or know the ware about of Allah so we should leave it to him we bleive with out condition Allah, his Malaa'ika, his prophet, his Books, And the day of reserection and good and bad is from him and the return from death ) But the kawaarij then change the name to israafiya then mahkama then (wahaabi through this group devided to ikhwan muslimiin, Al itihaad, Salafi,) then know the Salafi jidiid are the new group
I fallow Imaam Shafi'a Madhab And my aqiida is Ash'ari same as Imaam Dahaawi please anyone can correct me if i am wrong

Omar

16-12-06, 02:20 PM

http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=7&ID=890&CATE=1&redirect=yes

:up::up::up::up:

`asiya

16-12-06, 02:54 PM

http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=5523&ln=eng

:up: :up: :up: :up: :up: :up:

MuslimWays

16-12-06, 03:40 PM

"O you who believe! A group of people should not scorn another group, for it may be that (the scorned person) is better than the other…"
Soorah al-Hujurat (49): 11

MMS

16-12-06, 04:03 PM

aherm :embar:

The holy Prophet(Sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) said " Allah will never allow my Ummah to unite upon misguidance and incorrect beliefs. Allah's mercy, blessings and protection are with the largest group of Muslims. And he who deviates from this largest group of Muslims will be thrown into Hell." [ Tirmizi]

:outta:

great post MMS :embar:

Ibn Khattab

16-12-06, 04:11 PM

couple of ma mates are hanafi, others follow imam shafi. im pakistani :D

Eemaan

16-12-06, 04:23 PM

couple of ma mates are hanafi, others follow imam shafi. im pakistani :D

yiou aint even a proper one of those :smack:

your confused lil bhai :D

alld

16-12-06, 04:47 PM

couple of ma mates are hanafi, others follow imam shafi. im pakistani :D

i am confused brother ....pakistani a madhab pathan balooch punjab sindh :confused: :p

Ibn Khattab

16-12-06, 08:25 PM

loool a PATHAN at tht :D :D

Hayati

17-12-06, 02:54 AM

Assalaam aleikum

I follow hanafi

alld

17-12-06, 05:21 AM

loool a PATHAN at tht :D :D

pat the pathan :D :up:

Arifa

19-12-06, 02:44 PM

bump for new members

alld

19-12-06, 02:49 PM

will Allah swt ask us on day of judgement if we are supposed to have been hanafi ,hanbali or maliki ???

Arifa

19-12-06, 03:03 PM

I don't think so

acedoc

19-12-06, 08:08 PM

yeah, Mashalah we have some very knowledgeable brothers and sisters here... who have the ability to do this. :rolleyes:

Hwo could one be so "knowledgable" when they can NOT tell weak and fabricated hadiths from an authentic one. Neitehr Allah nor His prophet want abunch of sheep who follow blindly whosoever claims to be a scholar. If muslism want to prosper they will have to take responsibility of learning what is authentic and who is simply following their desire and wishful thinking...and worst yet their fathers/grandafters madhab.

May alah guide us all. Wake up muslims

MangoChutney

20-12-06, 05:50 AM

hanafi

Hamza Momand

20-12-06, 06:05 AM

hanafi

Abu Mus'ab

20-12-06, 06:50 AM

Hanafi.

Umm Amjad

20-12-06, 05:27 PM

Remember the madhhabs of the Imams is the madhab of rasululah

We have many Hanafi's .. that shows that there are many asians on this forum. walahuta3alam

wasalamo3alaikumwara7matulahiwabarakatuh
(SAW)

Abu Mus'ab

20-12-06, 05:37 PM

ayeah-geeza

23-12-06, 03:41 PM

Salafi's are those who claim the true followers of the Salaf (The word Salaf means arabic is people of the past)
1> You might ask yourself are they new group well No, they change name's every centry to confuse the people.

Topyes do you really like to listen to the raafidists?? cuz u sound like one.
First salafism isn't a madhab, just to make it clear. The prophet said to his daughter that he is a salaf. and u can see the true meaning of salaf on wikipedia.com
All sunnis are salaf dont split us apart, yes there is a group called salafis but they are just a political party in Saudi Arabia. But we are talking about the true salafis within islam.

Raafidists are trying to say that salafis are not within the sunnah wal jama'a. Now tell me which sunni doesn't listen to the scholars ibn baz, ibn alithaeemin, al albany..ect

secondly why are you members here in this forum discussing anything about madhabs.. there is no difference between the madhabs just some basics, and some of the imams was students of others.

MuslimWays

23-12-06, 04:03 PM

masha'Allah, well said.

I think moderators should consider removing this sort of polls, which creates fitnah (confusion, disagreement, arguments).

Abu Mus'ab

23-12-06, 04:13 PM

No fitnah is created from threads like this, if anyone doesn't want to participate then by all means dont.

ayeah-geeza

24-12-06, 12:52 PM

No fitnah is created from threads like this, if anyone doesn't want to participate then by all means dont.

Salam Alikum

actually there is, by all wanting to support their madhab and beliefe..
this has been happening before. and many sunnis calling eachother for ahlul bid'a.

Abu Mus'ab

24-12-06, 12:59 PM

Salam Alikum

actually there is, by all wanting to support their madhab and beliefe..
this has been happening before. and many sunnis calling eachother for ahlul bid'a.
I'd like to see some examples of what you speak, because i've neer seen it happen here.

ayeah-geeza

24-12-06, 08:18 PM

I'd like to see some examples of what you speak, because i've neer seen it happen here.

you asked for it.. and the example is not here it in the islamic world today. Can you tell me why some sunnis call other sunnis wahhabist/ahlul bid'a/kuffar/mushrikeen??

ohh I'll tell you, cuz they have been debating which and which beliefe is right.

Can you tell me why there are sunnis doing so much takfeer. We should be united and by not being united we will make the kuffar and raafidist stronger.

Abu Mus'ab

24-12-06, 08:52 PM

you asked for it.. and the example is not here it in the islamic world today. Can you tell me why some sunnis call other sunnis wahhabist/ahlul bid'a/kuffar/mushrikeen??

ohh I'll tell you, cuz they have been debating which and which beliefe is right.

Can you tell me why there are sunnis doing so much takfeer. We should be united and by not being united we will make the kuffar and raafidist stronger.
You're blowing things way out of proportion.

1: Only barelwis call salafis wahabies

2: no sunnis make takfeer of other sunnis

3: sunnis dont even make takfir of the ahlul bid'ah (like barelwis)

4: i sense you don't know your aqeedah

There is only unity on haq not on baatil.

You made such stupid 'points' that is not even worth replying to.

ayeah-geeza

24-12-06, 08:59 PM

1: Only barelwis call salafis wahabies

and where did u get that from.. no actually not only they do that, many sunnis do too.

2: no sunnis make takfeer of other sunnis

haah says who??

sunnis dont even make takfir of the ahlul bid'ah (like barelwis)

but they call them ahulul bid'a,, and call shiahs kaffirs(some of them)

4: i sense you don't know your aqeedah

what have my aqeedah to do with this!!

You made such stupid 'points' that is not even worth replying to.

next time dont reply if you think it's stupid and not worth..!!

Abu Mus'ab

24-12-06, 09:12 PM

and where did u get that from.. no actually not only they do that, many sunnis do too.

haah says who??

but they call them ahulul bid'a,, and call shiahs kaffirs(some of them)

what have my aqeedah to do with this!!

next time dont reply if you think it's stupid and not worth..!!
Like i said before you have no knowledge of what you're speaking about.

haah says who??

says i

but they call them ahulul bid'a,, and call shiahs kaffirs(some of them)

And?

Barelwis are ahlul bid'ah,and shias are kaafir.

what have my aqeedah to do with this!

it's got a lot to do with it, if your aqeedah is corrupt then you're a deviant,that's how all the murtad/munafiqeen/bid'ah groups went astray because their aqeedah was not correct.

MuslimWays

24-12-06, 10:10 PM

Come on brothers, chillax, lets take a deep breath and remember why we are in this forum. thats to share knowledge, not to call each other sect names, to be honest I hate these kind of polls, because it always ends up with debates, and most of the time some smart guy starts saying things against salafis.

It's like they are the main target, and I see non salafi brothers saying salafi's attack other sects, when it's soo clear that its the other way round.

I am not a salafi, I don't want to restrict myself in a boundary of sects, completely wrong thing to do as a muslim.

ayeah-geeza

25-12-06, 02:47 PM

Salam Alikum

how are you MW? I agree with you I hate these polls cuz it leads to debates and I told the brother but he didn't believe me.. and as a result we are debating now. I also agree that sunnis attack salafis sometimes and claim that they are attacked by salafis. I am a follower of alsalaf al saleeh but sadly some sunnis claim that salafis are not sunnis but wahhabis, and start calling names. If you can read my first post down here u can see that I dont like these polls as we all are sunnis.. following the sunnah of allah(swt) and the prophet(pbuh).

Barelwis are ahlul bid'ah,and shias are kaafir.

and you have no right to call them kaffirs, who are you to tell people if they are kaffirs or not. See what did I tell you, you start calling names-ahlul bid'a ect, and that is not the manners of muslims.

it's got a lot to do with it, if your aqeedah is corrupt

My aqeedah is corrupt, and I say thats how fitna is caused!

Abu Mus'ab

25-12-06, 03:05 PM

Salam Alikum

how are you MW? I agree with you I hate these polls cuz it leads to debates and I told the brother but he didn't believe me.. and as a result we are debating now. I also agree that sunnis attack salafis sometimes and claim that they are attacked by salafis. I am a follower of alsalaf al saleeh but sadly some sunnis claim that salafis are not sunnis but wahhabis, and start calling names. If you can read my first post down here u can see that I dont like these polls as we all are sunnis.. following the sunnah of allah(swt) and the prophet(pbuh).

and you have no right to call them kaffirs, who are you to tell people if they are kaffirs or not. See what did I tell you, you start calling names-ahlul bid'a ect, and that is not the manners of muslims.

My aqeedah is corrupt, and I say thats how fitna is caused!

Wa alaikumus salaam.

I've told you before and i'll tell you again, you don't know your aqeedah.

What is your aqeedah?

What aqeedah kitaabs have you done?

Which ulema do you follow?

ayeah-geeza

25-12-06, 03:09 PM

Abu Mus'ab

25-12-06, 03:21 PM

at least you can write salam alikum.

I know my aqeedah, I am a sunni following the salaf.
I dont follow any scholars or imams, and its not important.

and tell me what are u, and why do you have soo much hate for other muslims.
Everyone can say 'i know my aqeedah' now prove it to me,what aqeedah kitaabs have you done?

oh so you're one of them 'free thinkers', that makes sense.

as for me, i'm a human, with an extreme hate for kufr and baatil.

MMS

25-12-06, 07:28 PM

Salam Alikum

how are you MW? I agree with you I hate these polls cuz it leads to debates and I told the brother but he didn't believe me.. and as a result we are debating now. I also agree that sunnis attack salafis sometimes and claim that they are attacked by salafis. I am a follower of alsalaf al saleeh but sadly some sunnis claim that salafis are not sunnis but wahhabis, and start calling names. If you can read my first post down here u can see that I dont like these polls as we all are sunnis.. following the sunnah of allah(swt) and the prophet(pbuh).

and you have no right to call them kaffirs, who are you to tell people if they are kaffirs or not. See what did I tell you, you start calling names-ahlul bid'a ect, and that is not the manners of muslims.

My aqeedah is corrupt, and I say thats how fitna is caused!

what is offensive about being called wahabbi :scratch:

MuslimWays

25-12-06, 07:57 PM

as for me, i'm a human, with an extreme hate for kufr and baatil.

Sooooo... brother... you trying to call the people who follows the teachings of Ahlus sunnah wal Jamah kufr? because I am sure you are intellengent enough to know the consiquences of calling a believer a disbeliever.

anyways I am not gonna argue with you, I try arguing fellow muslim brothers, you believe what you think is right, and I can not judge you for that, only Allah can judge his creation.

ayeah-geeza, don't fall into the whispers of shaytaan, and fall into debates, thats how he takes advantages.

what is offensive about being called wahabbi

I am not sure, but I am gonna take a wild guess, so not sure if I be right... okkkk... so here it goes... are you ready for this?... are you sure?

i think...

you know cos...

Abdul Wahab was a person...

and if you say someone is wahabi....

you are trying to imply they follow Abdul Wahab...

which is incorrect, because we follow our beloved Prophet (peace and blessings me upon him)

MMS

25-12-06, 08:02 PM

Sooooo... brother... you trying to call the people who follows the teachings of Ahlus sunnah wal Jamah kufr? because I am sure you are intellengent enough to know the consiquences of calling a believer a disbeliever.

anyways I am not gonna argue with you, I try arguing fellow muslim brothers, you believe what you think is right, and I can not judge you for that, only Allah can judge his creation.

ayeah-geeza, don't fall into the whispers of shaytaan, and fall into debates, thats how he takes advantages.

I am not sure, but I am gonna take a wild guess, so not sure if I be right... okkkk... so here it goes... are you ready for this?... are you sure?

i think...

you know cos...

Abdul Wahab was a person...

and if you say someone is wahabi....

you are trying to imply they follow Abdul Wahab...

which is incorrect, because we follow our beloved Prophet (peace and blessings me upon him)

would that mean hanafi shafi'i etc are all offensive labels :confused:

Abu Mus'ab

25-12-06, 08:07 PM

Originally Posted by MuslimWays
Sooooo... brother... you trying to call the people who follows the teachings of Ahlus sunnah wal Jamah kufr? because I am sure you are intellengent enough to know the consiquences of calling a believer a disbeliever.

anyways I am not gonna argue with you, I try arguing fellow muslim brothers, you believe what you think is right, and I can not judge you for that, only Allah can judge his creation.

Don't try to misquote me, show me where i've called someone from the Ahlus Sunnah a kaafir.

MuslimWays

26-12-06, 10:40 AM

would that mean hanafi shafi'i etc are all offensive labels

If people don't, then I would be worried for them, because we are not the followers of Imam Shafi or Hanafi (Rahimullah), we respect them and use their understanding in matters of deen as they were the great scholars.

Also if we really wna follow them, then we should not say we are shafi or Hanafi, did Imam hanafi say he's part of the hanafi sect? no oviously not.

Don't try to misquote me, show me where i've called someone from the Ahlus Sunnah a kaafir.

oh... look theres clouds on the sky, nice

Abu Mus'ab

26-12-06, 12:30 PM

There's no clouds 'on' the sky *Roll Eyes*

ayeah-geeza

26-12-06, 11:22 PM

Salam Alikum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh

Also if we really wna follow them, then we should not say we are shafi or Hanafi, did Imam hanafi say he's part of the hanafi sect? no oviously not.

true, he was a muslim. Many times allah in the quran says that the prophets were muslims..muslims. So we don't want to be split apart.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3nr7BGzfeXw&feature=PlayList&p=442C6DE2EA016701&index=0

ayeah-geeza, don't fall into the whispers of shaytaan, and fall into debates, thats how he takes advantages.

Thanks 4 the advice.. I dont really want to debate, but its very sad to see him saying that other muslims are kuffar. Thats what he said about the shias.
I am going to check your website inshallah:)

what is offensive about being called wahabbi

well firstly the people that hated muhammed bin abdul wahhab called the muslims who agreed with him wahhabis. Muhammed ibn abdul wahhab didn't make any school of thoughts he was just following the salaf way of ahlul sunnah wal jama'a.
secondly its not good to say wahhabi.. allah's name is al wahab!

Honey87

07-01-07, 11:22 PM

yea the 4 imams themselves told us that if something they said was wrong to throw it against a wall. and yes u can folow all 4 madhhabs you can take whichever ones got more proofs.

i am not sure if this has already been said, but to my knowledge when the four imams said '..throw against the wall' they were saying that to other scholars. i'll try n find a link.

Mujaheedah

08-01-07, 11:38 AM

i am not sure if this has already been said, but to my knowledge when the four imams said '..throw against the wall' they were saying that to other scholars. i'll try n find a link.
other scholars, as in the other imams

miss-islamic

11-01-07, 07:08 PM

Hanafi. Grew up with dedobani teachings which is strict hanafi…

Abu Mus'ab

11-01-07, 07:21 PM

Hanafi. Grew up with dedobani teachings which is strict hanafi…
But you're a shia?

miss-islamic

12-01-07, 04:02 PM

No. Grow up and get over your obsessive hatred with Shias. Our purpose in life is to worship and get closer to Allah (swt), not to hate shias or any other people.

p.s dedobanis hate shias as much salafees. Infact they agree and are similar on most issues except madhab and a few other ones.

$HugoBoss$

17-01-07, 06:12 PM

To be honest i have no idea, i'm sunni and thats all i know. I guess whichever one makes sense to me.

JiHaDiYa

28-01-07, 08:20 PM

me personally i take from all manhabs, i take what the majority says...if 4eg 3 of the manhabs say u hav 2wear socks n da only thing dat sud b shown was da hands n da face den i would take dis opionion, because they would have the most daleel 2back this up....but all 4 imaams were all hard workers in da path of allah swt, and may the almighty have rahmah on them, allahumma ameen

ayeah-geeza

10-04-07, 10:40 PM

But you're a shia?

lol, why would you think she is?

Miss-Islamic are you from Iran?

Abu Mus'ab

11-04-07, 08:03 AM

lol, why would you think she is?

Miss-Islamic are you from Iran?
That was a long time ago *Roll Eyes*

She's afghan if i'm not mistaken.

al faqeer

11-04-07, 08:19 AM

Did'nt realise that salafi is a Madhab ?

and people actually voted for it ! lol :)

Asmara

11-04-07, 04:51 PM

I follow a combination I think. Mostly Shafi though.

mirwais

12-04-07, 10:12 AM

Does anyone know wich Madhab most of the the great Hadith Scholars follow??

i heard most off them follow Shafi...but i've no source to proof this

Nazias

12-04-07, 06:50 PM

Did'nt realise that salafi is a Madhab ?

and people actually voted for it ! lol :)

:rolleyes: They probably did so as that is what they consider themselves.

perfectpearl

12-04-07, 06:51 PM

Salafee is not a madhab :smack: . Its funny how u put it ! :rofl1:

mirwais

12-04-07, 06:52 PM

does someone know wich Madhab most of the Hafiz of Hadith follow?

perfectpearl

12-04-07, 06:53 PM

does someone know wich Madhab most of the Hafiz of Hadith follow?

It doesn't really matter. They are all right. Follow which ever. Just cuz they follow a certain one doesn't mean u have to follow them too. Follow which one u think is more right. :up:

Nazias

12-04-07, 06:54 PM

Salafee is not a madhab :smack: . Its funny how u put it ! :rofl1:

People probably didn't think about the question, just saw the one they see themselves as :idea: end of!

... :scratch: who me? :o

mirwais

12-04-07, 06:57 PM

It doesn't really matter. They are all right. Follow which ever. Just cuz they follow a certain one doesn't mean u have to follow them too. Follow which one u think is more right. :up:

yeah i know Alhamdulillah:coolbro: but i still think its interesting to know....

perfectpearl

12-04-07, 06:57 PM

People probably didn't think about the question, just saw the one they see themselves as :idea: end of!

... :scratch: who me? :o

LOL...the maker of this thread!

Nazias

12-04-07, 06:58 PM

LOL...the maker of this thread!

Oh, that's ok then! :D

Abu Mus'ab

12-04-07, 07:09 PM

does someone know wich Madhab most of the Hafiz of Hadith follow?
Names? which ones are you talking about?

mirwais

12-04-07, 07:17 PM

Names? which ones are you talking about?

most of the Hafiz of Hadith...so if you have like 100 Hafiz of Hadith, what was the most followed Madhab of those 100? Hope my question is clear, i'm sorry my english is bad...

ayeah-geeza

12-04-07, 09:07 PM

People probably didn't think about the question, just saw the one they see themselves as :idea: end of!

... :scratch: who me? :o

there are only 4 madhabs, Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali.. salafee is not a madhab, most of salafis follow the Hanbali madhab.

most of the Hafiz of Hadith...so if you have like 100 Hafiz of Hadith, what was the most followed Madhab of those 100? Hope my question is clear, i'm sorry my english is bad...

Hanafi.. I think. I just heard many scholars of hadeeth came from the Hanafi madhab. I HEARD.. I am not sure if it is true.

Nazias

12-04-07, 09:19 PM

there are only 4 madhabs, Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali.. salafee is not a madhab, most of salafis follow the Hanbali madhab.

:smack: I know but people tend to call them salafis and not hanbalis! It's just the terminology people use!

mirwais

12-04-07, 10:13 PM

Why Does One Have to
Follow a Madhhab?
Debate Between Muhammad Sa'id al-Buti
and a Leading Salafi Teacher
©Translated by Nuh Ha Mim Keller 1995

http://www.masud.co.uk/ISLAM/nuh/buti.htm

ayeah-geeza

12-04-07, 11:16 PM

EXPOSING THE DEBATE BETWEEN SA'D AL-BUTI AND THE 'SALAFI TEACHER' LIES!

The Salafi Teacher was the great scholar Abbaasee. In his book, you will read it translated on the link I will give, he swears by allah this debate was not as Muhammed Sa'd Al-buti claimed.THE SITE:
The Errors (http://www.allaahuakbar.net/individual_callers/a_reply_to_al-bootee.htm)

mirwais

12-04-07, 11:21 PM

interesting...

Marwan

25-04-07, 05:55 PM

There was no debate. Dr. Sa'eed Ramadan al-Buti was showing a parable; conversations that never took place but fleshes out the argument on both sides.

Kind of like Plato's The Republic.

jzcasejz

25-04-07, 11:28 PM

ayeah-geeza

28-04-07, 08:35 PM

JazakAllaah! :up:

wa jazak

Islamiyyah

28-04-07, 09:15 PM

Salafee is not a madhab :smack: . Its funny how u put it ! :rofl1:

Thats what I was thinking, but I voted it anyways....

Ottoman

06-05-07, 04:38 AM

where are the options "all" and "none"..?

Phoenix CG

23-03-08, 12:50 PM

if it's all isn't it usually salafi?

Al-Zaara

23-03-08, 12:59 PM

if it's all isn't it usually salafi?

Exactly my thoughts. And 'none', can be 'Others' in the poll. And I must also point out that Salafi ain't a madhab, like many here have said... Hehe.

I myself follow the Hanafi madhab, elhamdulillah.

-Fady-

27-03-08, 01:13 AM

Salafi....to the bone....and the flesh....

abood

27-03-08, 01:24 PM

Quran and Sunnah

aboosait

27-03-08, 01:54 PM

Who is the Imam of each of these Madhabs?

Shaf'ee..................Muhammad Ibn Idrees ash-Shaafi'ee [769-820 CE].

Hanafee..................Nu'maan Ibn Thaabit. (703-767 CE)

Maliki..................... Maalik Ibn Anas Ibn Aamir. [717-801 CE].

Hanbali..................Ahmad Ibn Hambal ash-Shaybaanee [778-855 CE].

Salafee.................. ? ? ?(Salafees please answer)

Others...................? ? ?(others please answer)

Kasim2k7

29-03-08, 07:04 AM

I love Imam Abu Hanifa. His knowledge was great.
In the book Tazkarai Auliya by Imam Jaffar Sadiq under the heading of Imam Abu hanifa, it is said that once some women asked him a question and he was not able to answer so his daughter called Hanifa saw the stress on her father's face and asked him whats wrong? He put the question infront which was that a man can marry two woman but a woman cant marry two men. Why is that?
His daughter, Hanifa, said its simple but i will tell you one condition. You will be called Abu Hanifa from now on instead of Nauman because i want my name to get famous. When it was agreed so Hanifa asked the women to come in her room. When they were gathered, Hanifa gave them a plate each and asked them to take their milk out in their own plates. When it was done, Hanifa poured all the milk in one big bowl and she put the bowl in the middle and asked them to take your own milk out. The women couldnt do it because the milk was mixed. So Hanifa said, thats your question answered.
And from then Nauman Ibn Thaabit was called Imam Abu Hanifa which is ofcourse a great scholar. R.A

salahuldin786

29-03-08, 11:25 PM

hanafi all the wayyyyyyyyyyyyyy who us can boast that they learned from some of the companion's.

Abu Hanifa was also one of the Tabi'een, the generation after the Sahaba, because he saw the Sahabi Anas ibn Malik, and transmitted hadiths from him and other Sahaba

Abu Hanifa was born 67 years after the departure of the prophet Muhammad but during the time of the companions of Muhammad some of whom lived on until Abu Hanifa's youth. Anas bin Malik, Muhammad's personal attendant died in 93AH and another companion, Abul Tufail Amir bin Wathilah died in 100AH when Abu Hanifa was 20 years old.

s4bXX

29-03-08, 11:46 PM

I am a Muslim!

My Madhab is Islam and I follow Muhammad PBUH and Companions and Aslaaf asSaalih.

"And the first to embrace Islam of the Muhaajiroun (those who migrated from Makkah to Al-Madeenah) and the Ansaar (the citizens of Al-Madeenah who helped and gave aid to the Muhaajiroun) and also those who followed them exactly (in Faith). Allah is well-pleased with them as they are well-pleased with Him. He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow (Paradise), to dwell therein forever. That is the supreme success." [alQuran 9: 100]

I donot follow any particular madhabi school. But respect them because all Imaams followed Muhammad PBUH.

I want an answer: Tell me who Muhammad PBUH was? whether Sunni - Shia - Hanafi - Shafiee - Hanbali - Maaliki or what?? I think he was just a Muslim so I am just a Muslim.

Allah (swt) says “…establish the deen and do not make divisions in it…” (ash Shoora 42:15)

“And hold fast to the rope of Allah (i.e. Quraan) all together and do not divide….” (aali I’mraan 3:103)

Totally agree! im just a Muslim.

aboosait

30-03-08, 03:17 AM

your sister

30-03-08, 11:50 AM

slm
I follow 2 madhabs,too - Hanafi' and Shafi'e. In fact I only do my "salat" (prayer) like Shafi'e. All other things-like Hanafi':)

jus'me

30-03-08, 12:51 PM

Totally agree! im just a Muslim.

Following a Madhab does not deviate you from being a 'muslim'...Madhabs are a set of guidelines devised by our highly pious and knowledgble predecessors which are essentially derived form the Sunnah..

P.S;..i try follow the Hanafi madhab

salahuldin786

30-03-08, 11:39 PM

My dear Hanafee, please tell me which Madhab did Shaikh Nu'maan Ibn Thaabit. (703-767 CE) folow?

My dear Shaf'ee, please tell me which Madhab did Shaikh Muhammad Ibn Idrees ash-Shaafi'ee [769-820 CE] follow?

My dear Maliki, please tell me which Madhab did Shaikh Maalik Ibn Anas Ibn Aamir. [717-801 CE] follow?

My dear Hanbali, please tell me which Madhab did Shaikh Ahmad Ibn Hambal ash-Shaybaanee [778-855 CE] follow?

all madhab's go back to our prophet p.b.u.h all that he taught came through them the light of our prophet p.b.u.h shine's through them.

and to answer your boring question our nabi's madhab.

aboosait

31-03-08, 04:23 AM

and to answer your boring question our nabi's madhab.

Wikipedia says,

Nabi can refer to

Prophet in Islam
Prophet in Judaism
Butterfly in Korean
Nabi, the name of a singer/songwriter from Guelph, Ontario (Nabi Loney)
Les Nabis, a member of the 1890s group of Parisian artists
Typhoon Nabi, 2005 super typhoon
Northern Alberta Business Incubator, Canadian Business Incubator
North American Bus Industries, a major transit bus manufacturing company
Isador Nabi, a satirical pseudonym of Richard Levins and Richard Lewontin
Nabi Biopharmaceuticals, a Biopharmaceutical company based in Florida, U.S.
Nabi, a Korean input method for Unix platform

So you as a sincere follower accept that all the Immams followsd the Prophet Muhammed Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam's Madhab.

Do you also agree with me that the four Imams without exception PROPAGATED the Madhab of the Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam?

OR

Do you believe that each of them FOUNDED a madhab named after them?

Please bear with me if the subject seems boring to you.