Where does Allah ta'ala come from?

[Zydee]

salaam

Allah ta'ala made us. who made Allah ta'ala?

shukran

[nam]

Sallaam

Thats a circular question which you could spend donkeys years arguing about. What comes first, the chicken or the egg?. Allah has been there all along, thus no one made Allah (swt). The question you have to ask yourself, how can thier be a creator of a creator? If there was a creator of a creator would we not pray and believe in him rather than Allah (swt)? The answer is, logically, we cannot answer the question, becuase just like the chicken and the egg question, out intellect is limited. We only know so very little.

Thats my thoughts on it anyway...

Allah hafiz

YNam ("A red pen and a blue pencil, a combination for blue and red" nam 13/08/03)

[Tahiyah]

who are we to even ask this question? remember what happened to Musa (saw) when he asked to see Allah? you believe in your lord, you believe in the unseen. thats faith.

Allah is above all things created. all time. all space. we do not possess the mental faculties to comprehend Allah.

even if you attempt to imagine Allah, you are associating him with something "created", as that is all man knows, but our Lord and Creator is above creation. He is unlike anything we know.

"he begets not, nor is he begotten, and there are none equal to him"


Be careful and inshaa Allah seek refuge in Allah from shayton always.

[AbuMubarak]

the question is haram