Quick Q

[zahra_unknown]

I was just wondering..

You know when your praying namaz and you *atchu* accidently, are we allowed to say 'alhamdulillah' whilst your praying?

[al-ghazalli]

You know when your praying namaz and you *atchu* accidently, are we allowed to say 'alhamdulillah' whilst your praying?

If you are praying and you happen to sneeze then it is sunnah to say alhamdu lillah as reported by Imam Nawawi (Rahimullah) Al-Adhkar.

But the other people who are praying are not allowed to respond and say yarhamuka Allah, if they do their salah will become invalid.

This is based on a hadith in Imam Muslim's Sahih and the Sunan of Abu Dawud.

And this is the opinion of the Maliki's and Hanbali's.


And Allah Knows Best.

[zahra_unknown]

Jazakh'Allah

[Mullah_Din]

There is a difference of opinion:

A Hadith found in Mishkaat and Tirmidhi say that the Holy Prophet, Hadhrat Muhammad-ur Rasulullaah (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam) said that, 'Sneezing, yawning, drowsing, vomiting and nose bleeding in Salaah, are from (the acts of) Shaytaan,' On account of this Hadith, the Ulama say that it's all right to say Al Hamdu Lillaah. However, in Bahaare Shari'ah it states that if anyone sneezes during Salaah then he should keep quite. However, if he says Al Hamdu Lillaah, there no harm. But,if he did not praise Allah Taa'la, then, he should after completing his Salaah.

Wassalaam,

[Abu 'Abdullaah]

As-salaamu 'Alaikum Mullah Din,

What does 'Bahaare Shari''ah' mean?