PDA

View Full Version : Eesa Barot's Letter to the Ummah


Nazias
21-11-07, 08:55 PM
Eesa Barot's Letter to the Ummah

Eesa (Dhiren) Barot, was arrested in August 2004 and held for over two and a half years in the High Secure Unit at HMP Belmarsh. He was convicted in November 2006 over the Gas Limos Plot and sentenced to 40 years minimum without parole (later reduced on appeal to 30 years). Eesa was subsequently transferred to HMP Frankland where he was brutally burnt with boiling oil by fellow inmates. Al-istiqamah.com is pleased to publish this exclusive letter written by Eesa to us which reveals an alarming picture of institutionalised racism and islamaphobia facing Muslim inmates in UK prisons.

Assalamu Alaikum w.r. w.b.,

Just over three months have passed since the recent event that encompassed me. Unfortunately, I still have a long way to go; my injuries are quite debilitating. Though my grading on paper is officially AA High Risk, I could tell you grim stories of how in reality it is more reflective of AAA Exceptional Risk. My point here is not to suggest 'pity me' — God forbid. But it is with a view to educate other Muslims and let them know that my world is greatly different from other inmates since arguably I have been transformed/considered to be the UK's most ill-reputed prisoner — a modern-day Freddy Krueger — even more so than Ian Huntley and others.

Oppressive Conditions as Compared to Other "AA" High Risk Inmates

Miss Arani who has a small handful of other AA Cat clients has commented on the heightened security that surrounds me. For instance, a snapshot day or week in my life even before coming to the hospital Unit would have read as follows:

- 3 intensive cell searches, including a strip-search over a period of only two weeks. 'A' Category inmates might only receive one over a three month duration and other 'High Risk' Category inmates would normally get one in two weeks - if that.

- 2 visits to the segregation block (solitary confinement) in one week under the guise of 'suspicion of having a mobile phone'.

- Being given an 'official' warning for allegedly failing to submit myself for a urine test under the assumption that I may have been guilty of drug usage! All under false pretexts.

- Being denied suitable Islamic literature/ CDs for several years under some excuse or another, save for the most elementary of titles. These are mostly from the Indo/Pak subcontinent, paralysed and jaundiced due to Government influence.

I am being kept in a state of semi-incommunicado - unjustified.

Setting the Stage for the Attack

There too remains the issue of keeping me at arm's length from other inmates. Any time the prison feels that I may have found a 'friend' that I may be 'overly' socialising with, more often than not the individual/s concerned are promptly shipped out to other establishments. Why? For irrational fear of 'sermonizing' or 'talent scouting' of course because they believe I have an arresting personality! The same goes for physical training with other inmates.

And of course nearly always being placed on the wings where there are next to no practicing Muslims, Asians or black persons and then them feigning surprise when I am half burnt to death. I was located in an environment where there were approximately 90 white males - excluding staff of the same - and merely around ten people of ethnic origin! Most of these people could well be described as the dregs, or underbelly (of society). Can you believe, the prison authorities are stating that this major imbalance at Frankland was a mere coincidence and are still attempting to retain me here as well as trying to extricate themselves from culpability. And certainly the Home Office, with their carte blanche attitude, has much to answer for too since the final decision rests with them.

It is far too convenient that although normally I am oppressively monitored around the clock — sometimes every fifteen minutes, every single movement recorded, be it exiting/entering my cell, shower, kitchen area etc — on the black day itself there were next to no staff around. There are many indications that show there was a treacherous trickle down from top to bottom, from government to prison establishment to the trailer park trash that descended on me.

Not only have I been subjected to mentally tortuous surroundings over the years (HSU etc.) but now physically too in order to break my psyche (and I don't just mean a mere beating that leaves a handful of bruises).

Delay in Receiving Medical Treatment

10% of my body has suffered deep horrific 2nd and 3rd degree burns. You'll be surprised to know that for the first three days following attack, although in unspeakable agony as well as being initially blinded in both eyes due to massive swelling caused by the severe head trauma, I was not even rushed to hospital, as any other prisoner would have been, regardless of category, since in my case security and financial niggardliness remains their 'first' priority and concern. It was only when Miss Arani threatened Judicial Review that the stance was changed and even then, though barely able to walk, I remained 'dog-chained' by wrist for four days under 24-hour intrusive bed-watch by four prison guards and armed police wearing body-armour who shut half the hospital down.

Irresponsible Media Coverage

There has been a great deal of emotive publicity lampooning me. Certainly, the incessant tabloid junk has wilfully served only to push me to the forefront of the prison population vilifying, character assassinating and generally creating many bad vibes for me.

Moreover, we also know that the Fourth Estate (the Media) in many ways is simply an extended tentacle of the incumbents at the Establishment. So ultimately the onus of what happened to me bears a broader spectrum shared by many.

Please also refer to the September 2004 fiction drama: 'The Grid' with leading actor Bernard Hill in which a 'home-grown' terrorist is jailed. In a final, deliberately emotive closing scene his jugular vein is slashed by other white convicts leading him to bleed out next to a toilet adjacent - by means of sarcastic innuendo - to an arrow pointing towards the Qibla (prayer direction for Muslims) and Makkah. Even though by and large it remains a quite unreal generally flop production, I had no doubt then, and now, that this grisly 'take' at the end was to drive home a real message to any potential young Muslim 'upstarts' out there. This being that one can expect mirrored treatment should they attempt to emulate or pick up from where other terror convicts have left off (those that are now imprisoned). In other words to drive the fear of God or 'terrorise' anyone from following suit.

Such images leave one to seriously question whether the media-controlling, manipulative Establishment actually wished for the like to transpire as part of their 'War on Terror'. In grim hindsight there appears now to be no doubt, evidently. Given also that on paper, terrorist convicts are compartmentalised (by the security agencies) as functioning in either 'operational' or 'spiritual' categories, (further sub-divided into 'sheep' or shepherds') it comes as no surprise that I was the recipient of such a yellow-bellied attack. No surprise because I have habitually been deemed to be the biggest scalp on these shores. And as for 'cowardly', that's precisely what my 'junkie assassins' were since they crept up from behind, under the guise of night, in order to 'jug me', dousing me first with boiling water and then with boiling oil. In spite of this, alhamdulillah, I was fighting two of them, since for a while I was a vexed powder keg that exploded.

Subsequently, now, it comes as no surprise that the prison brotherhood is starting to defend themselves and fight back using the same means and methods as employed by the white racists/Islamaphobes - perhaps you have already heard? Alhamdulillah. Even so, this doesn't detract from the horrific injuries I have already sustained. If you hang bait off a hook for long enough, fish will eventually bite. And indeed they deliberately placed me amongst the piranhas.

Lies Deliberately Leaked to the Press to Sustain a Climate of Fear

The POA (Prison Officers Association) have recently stated in a misleading statement, hackneyed to say the least, that Muslim terrorists are being targeted due to their crimes against innocents. In such case we beg to ask what of the crimes of the IRA that, whether intended or not, also resulted in mass civilian casualties? Or even David Copeland (and other white terrorists) the nail bomber who, by his own admission, attempted to start a race war. All of these Caucasian terrorists have been accepted amongst the general prison population and have integrated successfully without fear of reprisal. Hence it is cockeyed in the least to not see that racism and Islamaphobia is a driving force behind these heinous assaults - often supported by those entrusted with position and keys- that wilfully turn a blind eye. The message is clear: 'White terrorists' will be tolerated but outlandish ones not!

Moreover, in the false claim, again by the POA, that Muslim inmates have been attempting to radicalise others it is important to note that other than empty accusation, sourced merely from the 'prison grapevine', authorities have failed to provide any concrete evidence to support these baseless claims in spite of numerous cell searches, monitoring etc.

Where is the Support?

Although I am the author of this letter I emphasise that I, along with many inmates, at one point or another have repeatedly been the recipients of promotional leaflets/postcards encouraging support for other brothers, whose prison conditions are far less restrictive than ours. Frankly, it can be humiliating and incensing to have our noses rubbed in it — the lack of the British Ummah's (community's) empathy towards the rest of us — their sons too. 'Do not forget they too have given their today for your tomorrow.' Is there any to lend ear?

Do these Muslim organisations believe that we may be enjoying the backing of international power bases and thus we do not require domestic care and assistance? This is wrong, as wrong as can be, for we are not machines after all and require support as much as the next man.

The guys in the special HSU (High Secure Unit) at Belmarsh, where I too languished for over two years, also need a great deal of support since the environment there is near to being a segregation block and claustrophobic like no other. I hope the lackadaisical attitude of the British segment of the Ummah will end. For further info/updates please kindly contact the respective legal reps.

Miss A [Arani] (may Allah bless her and preserve her) has attempted to bring about awareness as regards my stay at HMP Service, which is undoubtedly red in tooth and claw, due to lack of voice and indifference from the silent majority. And I would not have it any other way. Blessed be the sisterhood; her, yourself and Yvonne [Ridley] and many others whom I know will never be muzzled from speaking out against injustice. Where are all the brothers in all of this, I wonder? Are they all inconceivably suddenly on something '007' that they cannot speak out? Or have they forgotten that I spent 32 years of the life Allah gave me on the outside, well acquainted from afar with their 'biryani and coca-cola' existence as coined sardonically by Abdullah Azzam (RH). May Allah in His Magnanimity grant us all the Hidayyah (guidance) and the Ikhlaas (sincerity). Ameen.

wassalam

Brother in Islam,

'Eesa Barot

Source: www.al-istiqamah.com (http://www.al-istiqamah.com)

ADZ w3
21-11-07, 10:40 PM
*sad face*

MNK
22-11-07, 03:01 AM
how can we help this brother out?

MWarrior
22-11-07, 10:54 AM
ORIGINAL LETTER (http://al-istiqamah.com/IF/BarotLetter.htm)
http://al-istiqamah.com/IF/BarotLetter.htm

al-istiqamah
01-01-08, 10:42 PM
Activist Must Stay At Same Prison (http://www.asianimage.co.uk/news/latest/display.var.1889785.0.activist_must_stay_at_same_p rison.php)

Please keep making du'a.

Nasibah
03-01-08, 02:03 PM
:sub: this is so sad. We should REALLY be more active in aiding our brothers and sister. Please let us remember them in dua. :crying:

Morris
03-01-08, 02:24 PM
I sympathize with him over the attacks he has suffered but this article is realy anti white. Just because 90% of one particular local prison population was white - he complains that he is forced to live with 'white racists'. Big suprise 90% of Britain is white. Or maybe he would prefer that in that particular prison in Franklin in Durham (that well known multi cultural hotspot) they should get some 'ethnics' shipped in - just for him. crazy.

Morris
03-01-08, 02:26 PM
Oh and Irish terrorists or suspected terrorists have never had it easy and been accepted in British prisons event though they are 'white'. The idea is absurd and actually insulting to Irish people who have suffered in HM prisons.

freetheprisoner
03-01-08, 05:31 PM
Hi Morris,

I think when he says "white racist", he really means it, i.e. National Front / Combat 18 / etc. A warden there until recently used to wear a Nazi tie to work (he got sacked a few years back).

I agree with you in terms of Irish prisoners however. It is because it was so long ago now ( or seems it ) and a complete blackout of that period of history is in operation, the Govt wants people to believe ireland was always divided, always had stormont, etc, etc, and so muslims and most people who are less than 40 , unless interested in the topic, probably think irish people got preferential treatment which if anything is the opposite.

For any muslims interested, I highly recommend reading about Irish history, you will see a lot of parallels between how our community is treated now and how irish were treated then.

MG
03-01-08, 05:38 PM
May Allah SWT make those that are guilty suffer for what is being done to this brother, may allah swt grant this brother and his family, sabr and relief and happiness once again ameen

al-istiqamah
03-01-08, 08:28 PM
Al-Istiqamah: The IRA, they did carry out a bombing campaign in the UK, yet they were given special wings when the abuse got to a high level, weren’t they?

Abu Abdullah: Yes but that is because they were regarded as “political prisoners” and Muslim prisoners are not given that title. Muslims are refused that title because then it gives them a cause. The IRA suffered a lot in the UK prisons, far more than the Muslims have suffered. They were members of an organisation. You have Muslims who are not members of an organisation, but they are members of a religion. Anyone can become a member of that religion, regardless of their skin colour.

The 'Terrorist' Label Never Wears Off (http://www.ummah.com/forum/showthread.php?t=153904)

firestorm
05-01-08, 05:45 PM
May Allah SWT make those that are guilty suffer for what is being done to this brother, may allah swt grant this brother and his family, sabr and relief and happiness once again ameen

This 'brother' confessed to plotting various terrorist attacks, as well as giving knowlege to promote terrorism that would kill innocent people.

What makes you think this isn't Allah's punishment on him for being a murderer? If it were Allah's will that he should be protected, nothing would harm him. He complains that he has been burned, he desired to burn others to death. He complains that he isn't getting his desired books and CDs, how many people did he hope to rob of everything they could ever experience in the future?

Can't you find someone else to feel sorry for?

Dappodan1
05-01-08, 06:22 PM
To all the brothers in the belly of the beast keep your heads up.

I dont particularly care for anyones politics, Muslim prisoners should be treated with justice equality and respect, this doesnt neccesarily mean that you have to agree with their tactics or the crime for which they are convicted.

Harold Shipman, Fred West, Ian Huntley, etc were all accorded protection in prison the people in custody are definitley no worse than these and even better as some of them havent been given a trial.

I rememeber in the 90's some prison officers thought it would be funny to allow the Gooch and Doddington prisoners in HNP Hindley YOI Train in the same gym. The gym Floor was covered in pools of blood afterwards, Prison Officers are institutionally racist and usually know everything on the block and instigate matters when it comes to Ethnics.

al-istiqamah
06-01-08, 08:29 AM
It's a sad state of affairs indeed to have people who do not know the situation in HMP Frankland, dismissing the incident as "Allah's punishment on him for being a murderer"

Firestorm, were you aware of the reasons why the brother pleaded guilty? Do you know anything about what has been happening inside Frankland? Perhaps you might want to read this report of abuse in Frankland:

Abuse of Muslims in Frankland Prison: Campaign Pack (http://www.cageprisoners.com/download.php?download=673)

Should prisoners have the right to "punish" whoever they feel fit to, many of whom are murderers and rapists themselves? Should prison guards be allowed to encourage prisoners to attack others?

The following article is a well-written piece. Btw, Eesa Barot was not just doused with boiling water, but boiling oil too.

There's no justice in a 'jugging'

Prisoners who attack other inmates may see themselves as heroes, but Erwin James regards them as deluded and cowardly

So-called "prison justice" is cruel, brutal and, as the recent assault on convicted "dirty bomb terrorist" Dhiren Barot demonstrated, cowardly.

Barot was reportedly scalded by a fellow prisoner in HMP Frankland, Durham, presumably because of the "unacceptable" nature of his crime. Such an act, known on the landings as a "jugging," is a classic prisoner-on-prisoner attack and is the easiest choice of violent action for the least discerning attacker.

Prison-issue plastic jugs hold about a litre of liquid. A quick fill from the landing boiling water dispenser (there to facilitate the making of hot drinks) and the weapon is loaded. To make it more effective, sugar can be added. This ensures that the scalding liquid will stick and effect longer-lasting damage.

Typically, a jugging is mounted from behind, often while prisoners are queuing for meals, although a better venue for the more craven used to be the landing toilet recess before the introduction of integral sanitation.

Waiting until the target was sitting with trousers around ankles and head bowed below the half door straining for privacy, as well as for relief, provided the perfect opportunity for the perfectly gutless to wreak agony and injury. With no upfront confrontation and little chance of any defensive retaliation, a swift swing and tip of the jug and "justice," along with a perverted sense of satisfaction could be achieved.

But who are these individuals who take it upon themselves to inflict pain on fellow prisoners? And on whose behalf is this extra punishment delivered? The answers lie in the prison hierarchy, the most insidious product of the primitive prison culture.

It used to be that armed robbers, especially those who ambushed security vans, were the elite residents on the prison wing. Sex offenders, particularly those whose crimes were against children, were at the bottom of the scale.

During the past 15 years or so, however, ever since hard drugs began to infect and undermine prison regimes, major drug dealers have taken over as the wing kingpins.

But while sex offenders still inhabit the lower ranks of the pecking order, it appears that they may have been joined by those convicted of bombings and bomb plots, people such as Barot, who was convicted last year of plotting to blow up New York.

Taking a swipe at those on the lowest echelons of the hierarchy has traditionally been seen as a legitimate response by the "ordinary decent criminal" types to crimes that society in general finds particularly abhorrent.

It is a view reinforced by gleeful tabloid reporting of such incidents whenever they happen (examples include the face slashing of mass killer Dennis Nilsen and the blinding with a pen of Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper).

Perpetrators cite society's contempt to justify their actions - the absurdity is often lost or conveniently overlooked. They are not, of course, the paragons of virtue, in the main being people also convicted of serious crimes and who invariably fail to give their victims a chance to fight back. And anyway, once a person has been convicted and sentenced to a period in prison, for whatever crime, nobody but nobody serving time alongside that person has any right to take it upon themselves to inflict further punishment, whether it be a jugging, a stabbing or a slashing.

The deluded who do so are no heroes, neither are they champions of decent values. At best, they are misguided pathetic characters perhaps corrupted by the prison culture. At worst, they are fearful, timorous cowards with not a chance of ever achieving any real hope of redemption for their own sins.

Despite the horrific nature of Barot's crimes and those of other high-profile offenders who commit the most distasteful crimes, nobody outside should take any comfort from such incidents. And the prison system needs to look hard at ways of undermining the negative prison culture that breeds the twisted logic that leads to their undertaking.

The Guardian (http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2007/jul/26/1)

firestorm
06-01-08, 04:40 PM
Are you saying this man is innocent? According to what I've seen, evidence was found on his computer, that he intended to use limosene taxis full of explosives to hit several targets and kill civilians. He confessed because there was overwhelming evidence.

He's complaining in this letter that he doesn't get the CDs he wants. They're actually letting this man use computers in prison? He should be locked up in a box.

As for his punishments, are you saying it isn't according to Allah's will? Does anything happen outside of Allah's will?

I am happy he is being attacked. He wanted to burn people who did nothing to him. He wanted to kill people who had mothers and fathers and children. This is the least he deserves.

al-istiqamah
06-01-08, 05:41 PM
I didn't say "innocent", but just that you are not in possession of the full facts of why he pleaded guilty.

CDs= Qur'an/Islamic lecture CDs as I understand. Mass murderers are allowed music CDs.

"As for his punishments, are you saying it isn't according to Allah's will? Does anything happen outside of Allah's will?"

I don't believe I denied Allah's qadr, but I am curious as to how you can determine if it is a punishment or test from Allah?

"I am happy he is being attacked. He wanted to burn people who did nothing to him. He wanted to kill people who had mothers and fathers and children. This is the least he deserves."

Do not rejoice in the misfortunes of your brother. For God may show him compassion, but create difficulties for you.' HADITH OF AT-TIRMIDHI

freetheprisoner
06-01-08, 06:04 PM
Salam alaykum, I think with regards this topic, there are a number of angles :-

1. Eesa has not actually been convicted of murdering anyone, nor has it been proven that he has done any violent act on any person, muslim or non-muslim.

2. The prison has an obligation to protect everyone under its care, regardless of the 'crimes', real or alleged, that a person has committed.

3. It has been said that an indication of a free society is how it treats its worst members, not its best. Eesa is certainly not the worst example of a person, and certainly not the best, yet look how he is treated!

4. In the world of the prison, who is judged a "good" prisoner, versus a "bad" one? The person who attacked Eesa was a convicted street mugger. He held up three students at knifepoint, including a woman. Is this a good person to be administering "justice" in your opinion firestorm?

I always thought the role of a prison is twofold :

a. To rehabilitate
b. To punish

The fact of inhibiting freedom of movement and removal of the right to participate in british society fully fulfils the prisons aim of "punishment". Further burnings / lack of medical care / physical and mental abuse is not required, and is prohibited under the european convention of human rights. There is no further punishment required...the purpose of the sentence is to illustrate the severity of the crime.

Ws

Umar

Nazias
12-01-08, 11:14 AM
:jkk:

al-istiqamah
29-01-08, 10:13 AM
Satpal Ram (released in 2002) has spoken out about the racism that he endured at witnessed at HMP Frankland. It is thus clear that it is not just Muslim "terrorists" who are potential victims.

He describes an incident - also at Frankland Prison - where, after a routine search, six prisoners were forced to strip naked and squat for anal searches. Satpal was not one of those involved but he was outraged at the way fellow inmates were being treated. 'This to me was a sexual assault,' he says. 'I made a telephone call to the Prisoners' Advice Service and requested them to provide legal intervention. The call was monitored and the next thing I know I am accused of incitement and taken to the segregation unit.' Many of the attacks and much of the intimidation he has endured have come, he says, garnished with racial abuse.

A farcical trial and 13 years of racist abuse in jail - the story of Satpal Ram (http://www.guardian.co.uk/racism/Story/0,2763,193365,00.html)

Please note that in the past, non-Muslim prisoners have commited suicide at HMP Frankland as a direct result of abuse from prison guards.
http://www.revolutionarycommunistgro...4/184_pri.html (http://www.revolutionarycommunistgroup.com/frfi/184/184_pri.html)

MWarrior
29-01-08, 10:22 AM
Aameen.

IRA prisoners were given a special wing,even paedophiles are given their own wings but these brothers are not. Its because the prison officials want these guys to be harassed, tortured, attacked and even killed.

He describes an incident - also at Frankland Prison - where, after a routine search, six prisoners were forced to strip naked and squat for anal searches
That is disgusting.:(

al-istiqamah
29-01-08, 10:32 AM
So the prison officials moved both of them to different prisons.

Indeed it says a lot that when you abide by the rules and are half-burnt to death, a transfer is rejected. Yet when you stab an inmate you can get a transfer :rolleyes: