Why does PAL DV use
4:2:0?
The best
explanation I can come up with why PAL DV went
with 4:2:0 is that both PAL and SECAM show
reduced vertical color resolution and better
horizontal color resolution compared to NTSC, so
4:2:0 seemed a closer match to the native display
systems in PAL/SECAM countries. As PAL DV was
intended as a consumer format for off-air
recording or camcorder acquisition,
multigeneration losses in 4:2:0 were considered a
less important factor than the optimization of
first-generation performance. PAL DVCAM also used
4:2:0.
When
Panasonic developed DVCPRO, they opted for 4:1:1
even in PAL versions, specifically for the
multigeneration advantage. Thus PAL DVCPRO decks
have the pleasure and responsibility of handling
both 4:1:1 DVCPRO playback and 4:2:0 DV playback;
they have extra hardware to digitally resample
the 4:2:0 signal and come up with a decently
synthesized 4:1:1. Sometimes there is a
reason for the higher prices that the poor
Europeans are saddled with when it comes time to
purchase gear...
|